Why FAD Diets Keep Failing You (And What to Do Instead)

Been There, Done That… and Regained It All

Let me guess.. you’ve started a diet, lost a few pounds, felt pretty good about yourself… and then, somehow, the weight came creeping back. Maybe even more than what you lost to begin with. Sound familiar? Yeah, me too.

And guess what? Despite what social media might have you believe, you’re not alone. Most of us have been on that frustrating weight-loss roller coaster. It’s discouraging, exhausting, and honestly, it feels like failure. But here's the truth…it's not you. It's the diet.

Diets Are Designed to Fail (No, Really)

Let’s talk about the harsh truth: research shows that up to 95% of diets fail in the long run. Why? Because they’re not built to last. Most diets are all about quick fixes: cutting all carbs, banning sugar, or surviving on 1,200 calories a day. That’s not healthy, and it’s definitely not sustainable.

Think about it like this: if someone told you to hold your breath underwater for as long as possible, eventually you'd have to come up for air. Dieting is kind of like that. You can restrict and deprive yourself for only so long before your body, and your brain, snap back hard.

The Diet Rebound Is Real

Here’s what usually happens: You start a diet. You feel hungry all the time. You crave everything you're “not allowed” to eat. Eventually, you give in. You eat the cookie, or the chips, or the entire pizza. Then you feel guilty. And then you quit, right?

That cycle isn’t your fault. It’s literally how our bodies are wired. The more you restrict, the more your body pushes back.

Your Body Isn’t Broken. It’s Doing Its Job.

Here’s a little science (I promise to keep it simple): when you cut calories, your metabolism slows down. It’s called metabolic adaptation. Your body thinks you’re starving, so it goes into low power mode—kind of like your phone on battery saver.

Then there are hormones. When you diet, your hunger hormone (ghrelin) goes up, and your fullness hormone (leptin) goes down. Your body is basically screaming at you to eat. Again, not a flaw. Just biology.

Why Slow and Steady Wins Every Time

Your body also has something called a set point. Kind of like a thermostat. When you lose weight too fast, your body freaks out and tries to get back to “normal.” That’s why people gain weight back so quickly after a crash diet.

But here’s the good news: you can reset your set point. The key is doing it slowly, giving your body time to adjust without sounding the alarm bells.

So What Actually Works?

Here’s what I’ve found works. Not just for me, but for lots of people who are tired of the all-or-nothing mindset:

1. Focus on Protein and Fiber

Protein keeps you full. Fiber keeps your digestion happy and helps with cravings. Try to build every meal around these two things. Think eggs and veggies, chicken and quinoa, Greek yogurt with berries. Easy stuff.

2. Stop Labeling Foods as “Good” or “Bad”

As soon as you say “I can’t have that,” your brain becomes obsessed with it. Instead, try this: aim for 80% whole, nutrient-dense foods and 20% whatever brings you joy. Balance, not perfection.

3. Strength Train Like a Boss

Yes, cardio is fine, but lifting weights builds muscle. And muscle helps you burn more calories even when you're lying on the couch. Think of muscle as your secret weapon.

4. Sleep and Stress Matter More Than You Think

Not sleeping enough? Super stressed out? Your body is more likely to hold onto fat. Sleep is like recharging your phone. If it’s not fully charged, nothing else works right.

5. Play the Long Game

Instead of asking, “How fast can I lose 10 pounds?” ask, “What habits can I build that will help me feel better forever?” This is about your life, not just a number on the scale.

You Don’t Need Another Diet. You Need a Strategy.

Look, you don’t need another trendy crash diet. What you do need is a plan that works for you. Something sustainable, flexible, and rooted in what science actually tells us about how our bodies work.

If you’ve been blaming yourself, I hope this helps you see things differently. You’re not lazy. You’re not weak. You’ve just been given a broken system. But now, you know better.

Let’s stop chasing perfection and start focusing on progress. You’ve got this.

And if this hit home for you, stick around, because I’m just getting started with sharing what actually helps real people feel better in their bodies, for good!

Real change doesn’t have to be overwhelming. Sign up now to make it easier (and more affordable) to begin.

Michael Stephens is the founder of The GLP-1 Source, a platform built from personal experience navigating the overwhelming world of health, fitness, and GLP-1 medications. After struggling to find clear, reliable information in a sea of conflicting advice, Mike created this website as a straightforward, no-nonsense resource for those looking to make informed decisions about their health. Whether you're exploring GLP-1 medications, optimizing your fitness, or building sustainable habits, The GLP-1 Source provides practical insights, expert-backed tips, and real-world guidance to help you on your journey to a healthier life.